Call a Miami restaurant "the best" and the first question should be: by whose rules? A guide with anonymous inspectors, an awards program with a voting body and an open call, and a local paper with editors and a readers' poll all produce lists. They do not measure the same thing, and none is wrong for being what it is.
This edition skips the picks and opens the machinery instead, using each source's own published description. One caveat up front: we did not have Tripadvisor's published rules for review-data rankings, so that source is left out rather than guessed at.
Michelin: anonymous inspectors, a legend of stars
Who decides. Michelin says anonymous Inspectors traveled from the Panhandle to Key West to build its 2026 Florida selection, the first to be statewide (release). Hotels are chosen by Michelin Guide experts instead.
What is measured. The guide's legend ties each award to a meaning. One star is high quality cooking worth a stop, two stars is excellent cuisine worth a detour, and the Bib Gourmand is great food at a great value. A Green Star is for restaurants that impressed Inspectors with their approach to sustainability and gastronomy. Hotels are rated in Keys. The 2026 Florida selection holds 2 two-star, 24 one-star, 45 Bib Gourmand and 129 recommended restaurants, 200 in all.
What it can't tell you. The release we read does not say how many visits a place gets or how inspectors weigh one dish against another. A star describes cooking and value as the guide defines them, not atmosphere, service for your party or whether you can get a table. Time Out reports that Mutra earned its first star and that L'Atelier de Joël Robuchon Miami stayed Florida's only two-star restaurant for a fifth straight year (Time Out). Those are Michelin's verdicts, relayed by a magazine.
James Beard: a voting body plus an open call
Who decides. According to the foundation's entry page, an open call for recommendations runs alongside recommendations from the awards program's voting body (How to enter). Public recommendations for the Restaurant and Chef Awards are reviewed by subcommittees when the semifinalist list is generated. The 2027 open call runs through November 30.
What is measured. The page describes a process for gathering names, not a scorecard. Impact Awards recommendations go to the Foundation's Impact Committee instead.
Money. Restaurant and Chef recommendations have no entry fee. The Media Awards are different: $85 per entry, with waivers on request.
What it can't tell you. The page does not say how subcommittees weigh a recommendation, so a semifinalist nod can't be read as a ranking of that city's restaurants. It is a shortlist of names that survived a review.
Miami New Times: editors, contributors and readers
Who decides. The paper says its Best of Miami issue has run since the early 1990s and appears in June (New Times). In 2026 its editors and contributors gave honors in 340 categories, and Kat Bein edited the issue (2026 issue). A separate Readers' Choice poll drew over 192,000 votes and declared 141 winners.
What is measured. Two different things share one issue. Editors' picks reflect what the staff and contributors chose to cover during a production run of about four months. Readers' picks measure popularity among people who voted. Neither is a taste test.
What it can't tell you. The 2025 issue, edited by Liz Tracy, held more than 300 superlatives. A list that long is a survey of a city, not a single verdict. The paper also admits a slip: it left in the blurb for a barbershop that closed before publication, though it normally removes closed places. Check that a place is still open.
Side by side
| | Michelin Guide | James Beard Awards | Miami New Times |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | Anonymous Inspectors (hotels: Guide experts) | Voting body plus open public recommendations, reviewed by subcommittees | Editors and contributors; readers vote separately |
| What it measures | Cooking quality and value, by the guide's legend | Names gathered for awards, reviewed into semifinalists | Editorial picks, plus readers' votes |
| Scale in latest source | 200 Florida restaurants (2026) | Open call through November 30 for 2027 | 340 categories and 141 reader winners (2026) |
| Cost to be considered | Not described in the release we read | No fee for Restaurant and Chef recommendations | Not described in the pages we read |
| Can't tell you | Atmosphere, your table, how inspectors weigh dishes | How subcommittees weigh a recommendation | Whether a place suits you; check it is still open |
Quick answers
Are best-of lists paid?
The pages we read describe no payment for being considered in most cases: James Beard charges no fee for Restaurant and Chef recommendations, though its Media Awards cost $85 per entry, with waivers on request. Michelin's release says only that its Destination Partners provide restaurant plaques, and says nothing about fees for selection.
Who decides the best restaurants?
It depends on the list: anonymous Inspectors for Michelin, a voting body plus public recommendations for the James Beard Awards, and editors plus a readers' poll for Miami New Times.
Sources
- Historic Moment: MICHELIN Guide reveals first statewide restaurant selection for Florida
- Awards > How to Enter | James Beard Foundation
- Behind the Scenes: Miami New Times Best of Miami® 2025 Issue Is Live | Miami New Times
- New Times' Best of Miami 2026 issue is out now
- These Miami Restaurants Were Just Added to the Michelin Guide
Also in the network
- Coconut Grove Takes the Spotlight Along Biscayne Bay This November (miamibiscayne.net)
- The Letter: Los Angeles, Miami and New York in November (lamiaminy.com)
- MICHELIN's Santorini Debut Gives Lycabettus Two Stars (recommend-today.com)






