Roundup · every pick names its source

4 Miami Thanksgiving dinners that two of three local guides name

Resident, The Infatuation and Miami Living each listed Thanksgiving 2026 dinners, and four Miami restaurants appear on two of the three lists, each with its own stated reason.

Thanksgiving dinner table set with plates and glasses, a flower centrepiece and a roast turkey on a board, with bookshelves behind.

Three Miami guides listed where to eat on Thursday, November 26, 2026, and they are not the same kind of list. Resident is a directory: it listed 12 restaurants with menus, prices and hours as each restaurant supplied them. The Infatuation is a guide with its own write-up of each place, published November 13, 2026. Miami Living ran a magazine piece on fine dining. Four Miami restaurants show up on two of the three. That matters for a group choosing a dinner: when a directory and a second outlet both list a place, you get the restaurant's own details plus another outlet's description of the same meal. Prices below keep each source's notation, including ++.

1. Le Jardinier

Named by Resident and The Infatuation. Both point to a three-course prix fixe built around turkey: Resident says the turkey is organic, and The Infatuation says the roast turkey comes with the menu. Resident gives the details: service from 12:30 to 9 p.m. at $185 per guest.

2. Luma at The Ritz-Carlton Key Biscayne

Named by Resident and Miami Living. Both give the same reason: this is its first Thanksgiving since reopening. Miami Living adds that the feast is Italian-inspired. Resident lists $195++ per adult and $79++ for children ages 4 to 12; Miami Living lists $195 and $79.

3. Isabelle's Coconut Grove

Named by Resident and Miami Living. Both single out a four-course Harvest in the Grove dinner with live music. Resident lists two seatings, 2 to 5 and 6 to 9 p.m., at $155++ per adult, with reservations taken by phone. Miami Living lists $155 per adult and $75 per child.

4. Maple & Ash Miami

Named by Resident and Miami Living. The shared reason is a black truffle turkey plate at $79. Miami Living says it is offered next to the regular à la carte menu, so it is one plate, not a multi-course dinner. Resident lists Thanksgiving Day hours of 5 to 10 p.m. and a $15 chestnut stuffing.

5. Ariete, named by The Infatuation

Only The Infatuation lists Ariete in Coconut Grove among the sources here. Its stated reason is a family-style, three-course menu with roasted turkey and four desserts.

6. Elcielo Miami, named by Miami Living

Only Miami Living lists Elcielo among the sources here. It describes a six-course Friendsgiving tasting menu at $220 per person.

Carbone is two different restaurants

Carbone looks like agreement but is not. Resident lists CARBONE Miami in South of Fifth: a four-course family-style feast from 3 to 9 p.m. at $225 per guest, booked through Resy. The Infatuation lists Carbone Vino in Coconut Grove, a different location, with a four-course family-style Italian-American menu. Burlock Coast is also named by Resident and Miami Living, but it is in Fort Lauderdale, so it is left out of the picks.

Where the guides differ

The Infatuation also listed Cote Miami, Amara at Paraiso, Macchialina's $250 takeout or delivery package for up to six, and La Carreta in Little Havana for a Cuban-American Thanksgiving. Miami Living also listed CATCH Miami Beach's $60 heritage turkey meal and Kiki on the River at $55 per person. Resident's list includes L'Atelier de Joël Robuchon, a five-course menu at $325 per guest. A single-source place is less cross-checked, not weaker. A directory reports what restaurants provide; a guide or magazine reports what its writers chose to include.

Quick answers

Which Miami restaurants are named for Thanksgiving by more than one guide?

Le Jardinier is named by Resident and The Infatuation. Luma, Isabelle's Coconut Grove and Maple & Ash Miami are named by Resident and Miami Living.

How do the prices compare?

For multi-course dinners, the sources list $155 per adult at Isabelle's, $185 per guest at Le Jardinier and $195 per adult at Luma. Maple & Ash's $79 is a single turkey plate, so it is not a like-for-like comparison.

Are the two Carbone listings the same restaurant?

No. Resident lists CARBONE Miami in South of Fifth, and The Infatuation lists Carbone Vino in Coconut Grove.

Sources

  1. Thanksgiving in Miami 2026: 12 Restaurant Menus to Book
  2. 14 Great Miami Restaurants For Thanksgiving Dinner - Miami - The Infatuation
  3. Thanksgiving 2026 Across Miami's Fine Dining Scene